ADVERTISEMENT

If you are seeing this message, you may be experiencing temporary network problems. Please wait a few minutes and refresh the page. If the problem persists, you may wish to report it to your local Network Manager.

It is also possible that your web browser is not configured or not able to display style sheets. In this case, although the visual presentation will be degraded, the site should continue to be functional. We recommend using the latest version of Microsoft or Mozilla web browser to help minimise these problems.

Wiley InterScience

Health Services Research

Health Services Research

Volume 42 Issue 6p1, Pages 2109 - 2119

Published Online: 7 Jun 2007

© 2010 Health Research and Educational Trust



< Previous Abstract  |  Next Abstract >

Save Article to My Profile      Download Citation      Request Permissions

Abstract |  References  |  Full Text: HTML, PDF (Size: 91K)  | Supporting Information | Related Articles | Citation Tracking

Using Performance Data to Identify Preferred Hospitals
Meredith B. Rosenthal 1 * , Mary Beth Landrum 2 , Ellen Meara 2 , Haiden A. Huskamp 2 , Rena M. Conti 3 , and Nancy L. Keating 4
  1 Department of Health Policy and Management, Harvard School of Public Health, 677 Huntington Avenue, Room 405, Boston, MA 02115,   2 Department of Health Care Policy, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA,   3 Department of Pediatrics, Institute for Molecular Pediatric Sciences, CheSS, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL and   4 Division of General Internal Medicine, Brigham and Women's Hospital and the Department of Health Care Policy, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA

 Address correspondence to Meredith B. Rosenthal, Ph.D., Department of Health Policy and Management, Harvard School of Public Health, 677 Huntington Avenue, Room 405, Boston, MA 02115. Mary Beth Landrum, Ph.D., Ellen Meara, Ph.D., and Haiden A. Huskamp, Ph.D., are with the Department of Health Care Policy, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA. Rena M. Conti, Ph.D., is with the Department of Pediatrics, Institute for Molecular Pediatric Sciences, CheSS, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL. Nancy L. Keating, M.D., M.P.H., is with the Division of General Internal Medicine, Brigham and Women's Hospital and the Department of Health Care Policy, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA.

Copyright © 2007 Health Research and Educational Trust
KEYWORDS
Quality improvement • report cards • hospitals • referral networks

ABSTRACT

Objective. To explore the implications of current approaches used by health plans and purchasers to identify preferred hospitals for tiered networks using cost and quality information.

Data Sources/Study Setting. 2002 secondary data from WebMD Quality Services on hospital quality and costs in five markets (Boston, Miami, Phoenix, Seattle, and Syracuse).

Study Design. We compared four alternative tiering strategies that combine information on quality and cost to designate "preferred" (defined as ranking in the top quartile) hospitals. Within each market we identified the sets of hospitals designated preferred according to each strategy and examined the overlap in these sets across strategies.

Principal Findings. Compared with identifying preferred hospitals based on quality scores only, we found little overlap with the sets of hospitals that would be preferred based on cost scores only, cost scores after applying minimal quality standards, and an equally weighted quality and cost measure. The last two approaches, commonly used and intuitively appealing strategies to identify high-value hospitals, led to substantially different results.

Conclusions. The lack of agreement among alternative strategies to combine cost and quality data for ranking hospitals suggests the need for clear prioritization by payers and the application of more rigorous methods to identify high-value hospitals.


DIGITAL OBJECT IDENTIFIER (DOI)
10.1111/j.1475-6773.2007.00744.x About DOI

Related Articles

  • Find other articles like this in Wiley InterScience
  • Find articles in Wiley InterScience written by any of the authors

Wiley InterScience is a member of CrossRef.

Cross Ref Member


Just approved for publication!

"Employed Family Physician Satisfaction and Commitment to Their Practice, Work Group, and Health Care Organization"

By Ben-Tzion Karsh, John W. Beasley, and Roger L. Brown

Click here for an "early view."

One of the Top 5 Year In Research Articles For 2009

As Selected by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation
Year in Research Online
Voting Initiative

Geographic Variation in Public Health Spending
Glen P. Mays and
Sharla A. Smith

Click here to read it- Free.

Subscriber Registration
HESR

Health Services Research

Access these free HSR articles:

The Health Services Researcher of 2020: A Summit to Assess the Field's Workforce Needs

Collecting Patient Race/Ethnicity and Primary Language Data in Ambulatory Care Settings: A Case Study in Methodology

The Role of Outpatient Facilities in Explaining Variations in Risk-Adjusted Readmission Rates between Hospitals

Hot Topic

FREE Special Article on Flu Vaccinations

JOSH

Journal of School Health has published a special, early view article entitled “Strategies for Implementing School-Located Influenza Vaccination of Children: A Systematic Literature Review.” Read this important paper FREE for a limited time!

Read More